Kids and Birds: Exploring Environmental Education in Yucatán
Saturday, January 4, 2014
Short documentary: The Ripple Effect
Here is the short documentary I created from this experience. It documents the process of introducing birdwatching to children, and the positive ripple effect it has on their lives and others.
Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Week 7: Introducing Birding to Las Coloradas
(See photos of Las Coloradas here, and nature photos here)
If you are someone concerned about not just environmental
but also social issues such as government corruption, injustice, failing
education systems, paltry job opportunities, drug violence, and struggling youth; then Mexico is a fascinating and frustrating place to work. Even if you
are a strict environmentalist, you will realize that none of your goals can be
accomplished without also figuring out a way to alleviate the social issues here.
Although your greatest love may be the perfection and intricacy of undisturbed,
nonhuman ecosystems, you can’t help but notice the social problems everywhere
you go. At times you even seriously consider that industrialization and
development might actually be what’s best for the overall well-being of Mexico’s
life. Then you come to a place like Las Coloradas and you’re completely at a
loss.
On the outside, Las Coloradas (LC) looked just like all the
other coastal villages I had seen so far; dusty roads lined with square cement
houses and simple convenience stores (tiendas).
But there is a business here that makes LC very different from the rest: salt
production. LC owes its entire existence to a sole salt company (called a salinera) that extracts white mountains
of salt from the coastal wetlands of Ría Lagartos Biosphere Reserve.
Essentially, LC is nothing more than a developed encampment for the salinera’s
workers and their families. In this village of about 1,150 people, there are
only two main professions: saltworker and fisherman, with a heavy bias towards
the former. One result of this is that kids here generally have no desire to
study beyond middle school. Even if a youth does have a desire to do something
more than shovel salt or catch fish for the rest of his life, other opportunities
are scarce in Yucatán and practically nonexistent in LC. I was also startled to
learn of the unchecked domination that the salinera has over LC. Not only do they rule
the job market, but they also own all the land in LC and determine who gets to
use it and how. In other villages, if a man wants to build a house to start a
family, he goes to the police station and they allot him a plot of land. In LC,
one must ask the salinera for permission. One resident commented to me that LC
is more like Cuba than Mexico. In a strange twist, capitalism has provoked socialism.
The salinera has also used its power to prevent all forms of tourism, probably
fearing that it may draw workers away from its currently unlimited supply. As a
result, LC is considerably less aesthetic than its neighbors Rio Lagartos, San Felipe,
and El Cuyo, all of which host relatively rich Mexican tourists from the cities
during the summer weekends. Additionally, LC doesn’t benefit at all from the
thousands of beautiful flamingos that can be seen practically from town. Instead,
guides from nearby Rio Lagartos bring tourists and take back their money to their
homes. Never before have I seen a community in such a stranglehold by a single
company.
American Flamingos near Las Coloradas |
This isn’t to say that the people of LC are wallowing in
impoverished misery. There is a saying that some use to describe themselves, “Jodido pero contento.” Broke but
content. Many have accepted their basic possessions and are content to live simply
in peace. From an outsider’s perspective, the best way I can summarize it is
that it’s possible to be content here if you don’t have great ambitions. People
here are poor, but no one is starving. There’s little to do, but there’s little
you’re expected to do. However, if someone had a passion for something other
than salt, fish, or housekeeping, I would recommend they take the next bus out
of LC.
So going back to birding, when I came into LC I wasn’t just
thinking about how to teach the kids about birds, I was also trying to figure
out what birding could do for them. Tourism is suppressed, so future careers as
bird guides would be unlikely (although it’s not impossible for them to move).
It seemed even more unlikely that their parents would send them to a university
to study biology should they become impassioned to do so. At first, it
seemed like there wasn’t much point in teaching them about birding, but then I
asked myself, why do the rest of us bird?
Because its fun. Because it’s fulfilling. And for me, observing nature gives me
an outside perspective on life that helps me find and focus on what’s really
important in the world. I can’t point to statistics that will suggest that
birding can help these kids, but I can tell you that a fun, meaningful activity
is sorely needed in a place where kids spend the majority of their time
watching TV and grow up to be low-paid and often alcoholic saltworkers.
From July 20-23 I stayed on my
own in LC to help start a bird club after the workshop Niños y Crías had just
given. In addition to teaching kids, I also spent time with Wilma, the young
woman in LC who organized the kids for the workshop, to help her lead a bird
club after I leave. Let me now recount an average day in LC, quirks and all…
A typical day for me would start with being awoken around
5:15am by the roosters next door, an experience which I found to be as
obnoxious as it was rustic. An hour or so later I would get up, have my
breakfast of bread and a juicebox, get dressed, put on sunscreen and bugspray
(let the greasiness begin) and don my binoculars and camera. I head out into
the rapidly disappearing cool air.
Birding outside Las Coloradas |
Outside I wait for the kids to come meet me for a bird walk,
usually arriving 15 minutes late, or 15 minutes early Mexican time. We have no
form of transportation other than our feet, but luckily there is a large
expanse of good coastal scrub habitat and salt ponds just half a sunburn down
the road. Here we usually find Tropical Mockingbirds, Tropical Kingbirds,
Mexican Sheartails, and American Flamingos quietly grunting and feeding in the
salt ponds. As the sun slowly starts to bake us, I help the kids work through
identifying their newly discovered neighbors: “Ok so if it has a gray body,
black wings, and a long black tail, then which species is it?” (I must have
said this a hundred times now). The kids are somewhat quiet and reserved the
first day, but continue to open up as time goes on.
Learning to use a field guide |
After the walk I return to my cabin to read, edit photos,
and rest for a couple of hours. Around noon I walk down the dirt road to
Wilma’s grandmother’s house, or rather, cluttered area enclosed by cement blocks.
I spend a while chatting with Wilma and her relatives and then get to work
helping Wilma in some way prepare for starting a kid birding club. One day we
went over identification of the common species in LC, on another we drafted a
request for 10 binoculars and a guide to the birds of Mexico from the American
Birding Association’s Birders’ Exchange.
Afterwards, I return to my cabin, which is nestled between one house that
sometime smells of burning excrement and another than perpetually reeks of something like burning vomit. Here awaits me the woman I have somehow managed to swoon…
Using the powers of peripheral vision, I discovered by the
second day that her gaze never left me any time I was within her sight. Every
afternoon and all afternoon she’s sitting at a table in the middle of the yard
that I must cross, and she stares at me eagerly and indiscreetly every time I
do. She’s tall and lanky like a flamingo, and has a voice strikingly similar to
one as well, which she uses to blurt beautifully intelligent things like, “He
just went swimming, hahahaha!” as I’m walking back to my cabin in a wet
swimsuit. Let’s just say that she looks and behaves nothing like I imagine my
next girlfriend will. So, on principle of course, I am obliged to resist her
not-so-seductive stare whenever I return to or emerge from my shelter. In
retrospect, it seems quite frivolous to write about now, but I believe her
persistence merits some recognition.
Next, I get lunch at the town’s only restaurant, my only
real meal of the day, consisting of grilled fish or chicken in corn tortillas.
There is little you can do in LC in the afternoon heat and humidity, so I go
back to my cabin and beat cool off for a couple hours more. At 4:30 I meet the
kids outside to go for another bird walk. Friday’s walk was a particularly good
one. This group of five loosened up more than usual and started joking around
during the walk. We
had great views of a perched Lesser Yellow-headed Vulture, a group of 20
Tropical Mockingbirds, and displaying Mexican Sheartails. I was thrilled to see
that one girl, Asís, was becoming very enthusiastic and skilled at birding.
Even after it rained on us as we ran back to town, Asís got the group to go
back out and bird a little more. To my surprise, it has been the two oldest
kids from the workshop who have shown the most enthusiasm towards birding. We
continued our walk towards the beach, spending about 20 minutes climbing a sea
grape tree like monkeys and eating the fruits. At the beach, the kids became
fixated on showing me the shells and spent the next 15 minutes tirelessly bringing
me every single type they could find. My hands overfilled with shells, the sun
set, and we walked back to town.
Photoshoot on our Friday bird walk |
Spending four nights in LC was one of the most wholesome
experiences I’ve had in Latin America. I lived more simply than I have in years. I shared as much of my knowledge as I could, but of course learned far
more. There is now a group of 10-15 kids in LC eager to keep birding. In a
place like LC, who knows what kind of impact this interest could have on their
community if they continue it? But as I have already mentioned, we will not get
to find out unless the bird club can find some binoculars to use. We
will be sending a request to the Birders’ Exchange soon, but I will conclude
this blog post by asking, sincerely, if anyone can help provide binoculars to
the kids in Las Coloradas. My email is emb326@cornell.edu.
Sunday, July 22, 2012
Week 6: Bird Class!
-Las Coloradas
Have you ever spent a day in a small boat bouncing among the
waves, and then suddenly experienced that exact same feeling as you lay in bed
that night? Well, last Thursday night I had a similar sensation, except this
time with sound. As I lay falling asleep in my hammock, I suddenly started
hearing a dozen young voices calling my name in little Mexican accents, “Ehvan! Ehvan! Ehhhvan! EHVAN!” I opened
my eyes and the voices stopped. It had been a long day with the kids in Las
Coloradas, but a good one.
This week I helped Niños y Crías give a birding workshop to
a group of about 16 kids between the ages of 8-12 in the small coastal village
of Las Coloradas. Starting on the morning of July 18, we began a series of
games, PowerPoint presentations, crafts, and of course, bird walks. I helped by
leading three bird walks, teaching the group how to use binoculars, giving a
presentation on the identification of ten common bird species, and leading
activities about habitat and reproduction adapted from the Cornell Lab of
Ornithology’s BirdSleuth program. The complete agenda of what we did is below:
Wednesday
·
“Map of Sounds” activity: Kids went outside and
closed eyes and listened for five minutes. Came back inside and drew what they
heard.
·
Presentation: Origin and Evolution of Birds
·
Presentation: The Importance of Birds and
Identifying Them
·
Activity: Draw a bird, something it eats, and
where it lives
·
Learning the body parts of a bird via
PowerPoint, song, and “Pin the Part on the Bird” game
·
How to use binoculars via PowerPoint and
practice with targets
·
Rules and ethics for watching/treating birds via
PowerPoint and charades
·
“The Secret Trail”: Practicing observation by
walking a small part of a trail and trying to find objects that were placed
there.
·
Presentation: “10 Common Birds of Las Coloradas”
·
Bird walk to along beach and through coastal
scrub habitat
·
List of birds seen
Thursday
·
Bird walk in coastal scrub habitat
·
Bird list and identification
·
Activity: Draw a bird seen on the walk
·
Craft: Bird Mobiles
·
Trip to the salt ponds to see flamingos and
shorebirds
·
Bird list
Friday
·
Review of what we learned so far
·
Presentation: What is Habitat?
·
Activity: The Four Components of Habitat
(BirdSleuth)
·
Game: Tag Your Habitat! (BirdSleuth)
·
Presentation: Migration
·
Game: Migration Adventure
·
Activity: The 6 Chapters of Reproduction
(BirdSleuth)
·
Activity: True or False? (BirdSleuth)
·
Closing ceremony and certificates
While it may have taken a while to get this part of the summer,
it was well worth the wait. The days were long and full, and for the first time
this summer I had a regular schedule (for two days) and a scarcity of free
time. But for the first time in my life I could go to sleep each night knowing
that I had probably made the world a little bit better. Although I have been told
that kids from the coastal villages can be wild, rude, and reckless, we were
lucky to have an excellent group of well-behaved and enthusiastic kids. Of
course, the level of interest varied from kid to kid. What you have to remember
is that this is a place where there isn’t even tourism, where the idea of
watching birds for fun isn’t quirky or dorky; it’s completely alien. To have
even one or two kids interested in continuing birding after the workshop would be a
success. Instead, we got sixteen.
I made a change of plans Thursday and decided to stay in Las
Coloradas an extra three nights to help Wilma, the local woman who organized the
kids, establish a birding club in Las Coloradas. This weekend I am taking kids
on various bird walks in the nearby coastal scrub habitat, teaching Wilma lots
about bird identification so that she can lead the kids in the future, and
helping Wilma solicit a donation for 12 binoculars from the American Birding
Association’s Birders’ Exchange program. I guess you could call this the
culmination of my work here this summer.
A couple times in the past I’ve gotten letters in the mail
asking me to donate old supplies or money to the Birders’ Exchange. I confess
that I declined these requests thinking that I was giving enough with my annual
memberships to organizations like World Wildlife Fund and National Audubon
Society. How mistaken I was. I can sincerely tell you that any money or
equipment you donate the Exchange will make an extremely beneficial
difference and is sorely needed. I cannot stress enough how badly Yucatán
and probably the rest of Latin America lacks basic birding equipment like field
guides and binoculars. As far as I know, there is simply no place to buy these
here, even if the average person could afford them. I have tried to emphasize
in this blog the importance of teaching kids about nature in order to achieve
effective conservation in places like Mexico where regulations are often
ineffective. One of the best ways to do this is by introducing them to birding,
as birds are abundant and relatively easy to see. Obviously, this cannot happen
without binoculars. If you sincerely care about preserving nature and spreading
a conservation ethic in Latin America, please make a donation to the Birders’
Exchange here.
Tuesday, July 17, 2012
Week 5: Challenges
It suddenly hit me this week how challenging this experience has been. The problem is, it's hard to walk into an NGO and expect them to have a job set aside for you. It hit me recently that every single week so far I have been nothing more than an observer. There has been no work I was actually needed for. The only exception was the class in El Cuyo I gave two weeks ago. Fortunately, the rest of this week actually does have an exciting plan involving a kid bird workshop in Las Coloradas and a flamingo festival in San Felipe, but the two remaining weeks thereafter are a complete mystery.
The idea of local conservation in one's own community is something that is starting to interest me a lot more. I won't lie, a good part of my interest in working in Latin America started with simple desire for adventure and exotic wildlife (don't get me wrong, there's a LOT if urgent conservation issues that I want to fix in Latin America). But one of the most important things I've learned from this experience abroad is the undeniable connection and advantage one has to working in one's own community. While my two homes, Wisconsin and New York, are certainly less exotic than places like the Yucatán Peninsula, they are places that I care deeply about and am much better connected to. Additionally, the conservation work there seems much more organized. Perhaps I over-estimated my ability to make a difference abroad at such a young age (20, in case that isn't clear). Perhaps it would be more productive at my age to be working where I am already somewhat established and connected. Later, if I am still interested in working abroad, I could apply the experience I would have gained at home to help me overcome the organizational challenges of working in 'Third World' countires. And there's nothing inferior about local work. Educating kids in the US may be even more important than in Mexcio because American kids are likely to consume much more resources than the poor kids in the villages I'm seeing. That's just a thought, but it's critical to recognize that US commercialization and globalization plays a huge role in driving and perpetuating the environmentally-degrading practices in Latin America. Basically, what I'm trying to say is that I'm starting to realize that some of the most important conservation issues are found in my own homeland.
You're probably thinking that I should be focused more on how I can make the most out of my time while I am here in Yucatán. I am too. There are certainly possibilities, it's just a question of whether they can reasonably happen. I need to find out if certain people are available, if I'll have a place to stay, if there is a group of kids interested, etc. One idea I have would be to help a young woman named Wilma in Las Coloradas start a birding club after we give the workshop this week. So I guess my only choice is to head to San Felipe with NyC this afternoon, talk to Wilma and the NyC staff as soon as possible, and try to work out the details in the next couple days. Any other suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
The idea of local conservation in one's own community is something that is starting to interest me a lot more. I won't lie, a good part of my interest in working in Latin America started with simple desire for adventure and exotic wildlife (don't get me wrong, there's a LOT if urgent conservation issues that I want to fix in Latin America). But one of the most important things I've learned from this experience abroad is the undeniable connection and advantage one has to working in one's own community. While my two homes, Wisconsin and New York, are certainly less exotic than places like the Yucatán Peninsula, they are places that I care deeply about and am much better connected to. Additionally, the conservation work there seems much more organized. Perhaps I over-estimated my ability to make a difference abroad at such a young age (20, in case that isn't clear). Perhaps it would be more productive at my age to be working where I am already somewhat established and connected. Later, if I am still interested in working abroad, I could apply the experience I would have gained at home to help me overcome the organizational challenges of working in 'Third World' countires. And there's nothing inferior about local work. Educating kids in the US may be even more important than in Mexcio because American kids are likely to consume much more resources than the poor kids in the villages I'm seeing. That's just a thought, but it's critical to recognize that US commercialization and globalization plays a huge role in driving and perpetuating the environmentally-degrading practices in Latin America. Basically, what I'm trying to say is that I'm starting to realize that some of the most important conservation issues are found in my own homeland.
You're probably thinking that I should be focused more on how I can make the most out of my time while I am here in Yucatán. I am too. There are certainly possibilities, it's just a question of whether they can reasonably happen. I need to find out if certain people are available, if I'll have a place to stay, if there is a group of kids interested, etc. One idea I have would be to help a young woman named Wilma in Las Coloradas start a birding club after we give the workshop this week. So I guess my only choice is to head to San Felipe with NyC this afternoon, talk to Wilma and the NyC staff as soon as possible, and try to work out the details in the next couple days. Any other suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
-E.B.
Thursday, July 12, 2012
Week 4: Teaching (and learning)
“Evans! There’s a tern over there!”
“Señor, my binoculars don’t focus.”
Me: “Here, Alvaro, you need to turn the-”
“Evans! Evans! Evans! Ev-”
Me: “Qué?!”
“There’s a tern flying over there!”
Me: “Ah nice job, Ismael! How did you know it was a
tern and not a gull? Jared, don’t go so far!”
“Its beak is orange.”
Me: “Right! And what color is the beak on-”
(Tug on arm) “Evan, I’m scared that it’s going to
rain”
Me: “ Ok, Monce, we’ll head back soon. Ismael! Why
are your binoculars covered in sand?!”
“Jared pushed me!”
Our first bird walk on the beach
Thus went my first bird walk with seven children in
El Cuyo last Wednesday. After my last-minute plan to
return to the sleepy village on the north coast of the Yucatán Peninsula to give my first bird class to a group
of kids, my trip became quite a bit more interesting. I spent the week
preparing for classes, teaching the kids as much as I could about birds, and
doing a lot of learning on my feet.
On our way to go birding
The class I gave was great in some ways and not so
great it others. The not-so-great part was its organization, which was pretty
hard to work with at times due to logistics out of my control. The great parts were
that at least a few kids got a kick out of watching birds for the first time
and that I learned a LOT about how to better organize a class. Unfortunately,
Chucho, the man who leads the two kid birding groups in El Cuyo and who was
going to help me lead the class, had to go out of town several times that week because
of the government elections, including on the first day. Consequently, only
three of the six kids he had invited showed up to the first class. We talked a
bit about birds and went to the beach to look at some Brown Pelicans,
Double-crested Cormorants, Royal Terns, Laughing Gulls, and a Black-bellied
Plover.
Birding with Chucho and the kids
Things weren't too much better the second day.
After setting up the classroom, I waited for almost an hour before the kids
started arriving. I had been expecting six, but nine showed up, and a dog.
While the six kids who were originally invited already had a year of experience
with birds, the three new ones had absolutely none. The class' age ranged from 5 to
11 years old, and I struggled a lot that day to give an organized,
entertaining, and educational class to such a mixed group of kids. There were a
lot of things I had forgotten about how kids act. For one thing, they don’t
seem to understand that you simply cannot listen to two, three, or even four of
them talking at a time. I did manage to teach them some groups of birds and the
basic parts of birds that day, and at the end Chucho and I took six of them birding
outside of El Cuyo, were we saw Black-capped Tityra, White-collared Seedeater,
Northern Jacana, and other birds.
Birding outside of El Cuyo
After two days of mediocre activities and
enthusiasm, it was time for me to step things up. Fortunately, by the third day
I started to get a better sense of how to control a group of energetic kids and
keep a class moving. The number of kids also lowered to about 7, which was a
relief. I think a couple of the original six dropped out, but it was
encouraging to see that all three of the kids new to birding had returned with
enthusiasm. I started the class by listing some of the birds from the day
before and helping them find them in the field guide, which the kids really
enjoyed. I had also realized that it was important that I myself had concrete
teaching goals for the day. Through a few games and activities, some adapted
from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s BirdSleuth curriculum, the kids were able
to list and explain the four main components of habitat and order the six steps
of reproduction by the end of the day. We concluded by birding for a while on
the beach, seeing mostly the same birds as the day before. For some, like
Mario, this was an opportunity to employ his birding experience by finding
Ruddy Ground-Doves for the group in the beach vegetation. For others, like
Yalila, this was their very first time going outside with the purpose of
finding and watching birds with binoculars. One of the most gratifying moments
of the class for me was when Yalila turned around and excitedly pointed out the
Brown Pelican that had just dove into the ocean. We all got great looks at a
Golden-fronted Woodpecker pecking for insects on a wood fence, and I was amazed
when the next day Alvaro, five years old and the youngest in the class, fluently
repeated its name (carpintero frentidorado) and what we had seen it doing. In
the last class we played another entertaining game about habitat, did a
migration obstacle course, and habitat treasure hunt. I concluded the class
with a bird walk to the other side of the village and a splash in the water.
Exploring La Ría on a bird walk
As I stepped out of the car full of kids after our last birding field trip and said my goodbye, they started chanting, "Que no se vaya! Que no se vaya!" We don't want him to go! I knew then that as crazy of a class as it had been, I had made positive impact. Trying to organize a class in a rural village can
be quite a challenge as I discovered. People generally have an extremely
relaxed sense of punctuality and obligation, especially the kids. Classes are
likely to start an hour late, kids may decide not to come one day, or they may
invite friends to the next class. On the other hand, there is a startling
amount of enthusiasm towards birds. Maybe it's because there's so little else to do in these small villages, but I've found that the kids here are way more excited to start birding than I've seen in the U.S. In El Cuyo and several other villages I
have heard stories of how kids rallied together to form birding groups after a Niños y Crías workshop. While I
may have gone into this class overestimating an 8 year old’s ability to
articulate deep thoughts on conservation, Chucho explained to me before I left
some of the exciting ripple effects teaching kids about birds he's already seen. Take a look at the video I put together of the highlights of the class as well as a part of my interview with Chucho:
Saturday, June 30, 2012
Week 3: Taking Initiative
Mérida
Ran out of things to do in Mérida this week, so I took the initiative to plan my own kid birding class for the coming week. I'm now off to El Cuyo, that first little village on the north coast, to give a 4.5 day class to 6 kids between the ages of 6-9 with very little birding experience. Here's what the general plan looks like:
Day 1
-Thoughts and opinions about birds
-Birding ethics, what to do and not to do
-How to use binoculars
-Prepare and decorate field notebooks
-List all the birds they already know
-Pick which kind of bird the kids will act as for the week
Day 2
-Go birding!
-Review the birds we saw
-Parts of birds
-Some basic groups of birds
-How to use a field guide
-15 common species
-Important things to look at for identification
-5 common songs
-Short birding walk to look at the things we talked about
-Draw a bird in the field
Day 3
-Go birding!
-Learn and play games about habitat
-Learn and play games about breeding
Day 4
-Go birding!
-Learn and play game about Miration
-Plan our surprise project (more to come...)
Day 4.5
-Work on project.
Ran out of things to do in Mérida this week, so I took the initiative to plan my own kid birding class for the coming week. I'm now off to El Cuyo, that first little village on the north coast, to give a 4.5 day class to 6 kids between the ages of 6-9 with very little birding experience. Here's what the general plan looks like:
Day 1
-Thoughts and opinions about birds
-Birding ethics, what to do and not to do
-How to use binoculars
-Prepare and decorate field notebooks
-List all the birds they already know
-Pick which kind of bird the kids will act as for the week
Day 2
-Go birding!
-Review the birds we saw
-Parts of birds
-Some basic groups of birds
-How to use a field guide
-15 common species
-Important things to look at for identification
-5 common songs
-Short birding walk to look at the things we talked about
-Draw a bird in the field
Day 3
-Go birding!
-Learn and play games about habitat
-Learn and play games about breeding
Day 4
-Go birding!
-Learn and play game about Miration
-Plan our surprise project (more to come...)
Day 4.5
-Work on project.
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Week 2: Flexible Learning
-Mérida
Before left for Mexico, I was warned to expect the unexpected when working with a Latin American non-governmental organization. Initially, I thought this meant, "Be prepared for things like last-minute changes of plan, walking alone in the rain through flooded city streets while searching for a cab home, and digestive dystopia." While all of this may have already happened in the last week, I did not expect to have to rethink the entire purpose of why I am here.
After settling down in the city of Mérida last week, I began working with NyC's environmental education team on their water conservation project. After the first two days of simply observing their staff give presentations about water conservation to students at an elementary school, I realized it was going to be a lot harder than I expected to do what I came here wanting to do: make a real and immediate difference by taking kids out into nature and showing them beauty waiting to be discovered. It finally hit me that because of various logistical reasons I wasn't going to get to do this until the middle of July, at the earliest.
Fortunately, that same day I met with Barbara MacKinnon, bird conservation legend in the Yucatán Peninsula. Barbara has been working in the Yucatán for over 40 years and possibly has more on-the-ground conservation experience than anyone else here. She is a true conservationist. Although she has conducted some bird population surveys, she quickly denies that she is a scientist. Chatting with her I quickly learned that we share many of the same frustrations with the limiting mindset of "pure science". Given her extensive background, she was the perfect person to express my summer concerns to. Among many things, Barbara reminded me that it is important to observe before doing but it is also up to me to take the initiative to do the things I want to do. She also told me that the most important thing I can do here is show local people their worth by bringing out the knowledge of nature they already have and showing them it is valuable.
The next two days I went with NyC to the rural village of Dzununcam to help conduct interviews with the landowners about their water use and contamination. While this type of work isn't why I came to Mexico, in these two days I feel like I gained more insight on Latin American conservation than I have in two years at Cornell. Throughout my travels in Latin America I have driven by dozens of poor villages like Dzununcam, but this was the first time I have spent hours walking through the streets, going into people's farms and houses, and actually talking to them. I wish I had photos to show exactly what this place is like, but bringing a camera would have been inappropriate so for now I'll play reporter.
The first man we interviewed went on a ten-minute rant about the government after we asked if he received any governmental support for his farm. He explained how he has seen over and over how political candidates come and visit his village, promise change and support, and then never return. He believes that the government is unfair and corrupt has no intention of helping people like him. The third person we interviewed was a man from Mérida who runs a tiny (and disgusting) pig farm in Dzununcam. While at first he tried to turn us away by saying he had work to do, after just a few questions he was showing us around his property and talking his head off about his problems. His place is absolutely revolting. In addition to the mountains of junk and garbage piled everywhere, the place reeks of pig feces. I looked into his well, the thing that we were there to interview him about, and saw that the shallow, black puddle at the bottom was moving, literally squirming with thousands of some kind of larvae. He brought us into his house, which is a dark shack extremely cluttered with rusty, damp, molding, and crusty things everywhere. Like the previous man, he receives no support from the government and angrily asserts that the government only cares about tax-generating people who work for large businesses. The rest, like him, are nothing more than animals to the government. Yet while he believes that the government looks down on him, he as well looks down with racism at the indigenous people of this village, calling them "indios salvages", savage indians, who have nothing better to do than go out and hunt wild animals. While we were trying to ask him about things like water contamination, he just couldn't stop telling us about how these "indians" are sabotaging his farm by poisoning his pigs and stealing his fish. He also sees them regularly going out to hunt birds, anteaters, and even Oncillas, a rare and threatened feline.
The place I have just described is actually part of an ecological reserve. If you have never lived in Latin America, you may not realize the disturbing lack of law enforcement there. It is not uncommon, I've found, for natural reserves to be heavily developed, deforested, and exploited. Three of the five people we interviewed didn't even know of the reserve they were living in. While declaring a forest a State Park in the U.S. may be enough to save it and its wildlife from destruction, I am starting to understand why it will not in Mexico. In countries like Mexico, it is more important than ever to collaborate with local communities to come up with solutions that benefit both people and nature. Otherwise neither will succeed in the long run.
This seems like an extremely hard thing to do. While I do believe that nature is essential to people, it's hard at times to see how to make the two work together. Granted, I have interviewed very small number of people, but most of them have seemed far too focused on their worries to ever care about nature. I don't know how to describe it exactly, but as soon as I look one of these people in the eye and began to listen to them, it feels overwhelmingly impossible to try to get them to care about nature. They just have too much else to worry about.
Which is why I wanted to work with kids. Even in these villages, they are generally happy and outgoing. It was quite a curveball to realize that I'm not going to work with them as much as I thought I would this summer, but I am learning to make the most of this as a learning experience. The biggest change is that for at least half of the summer I will be just learning, instead of teaching and learning. But the things I'm learning are extremely important to my future in conservation. I have learned that rural people will not trust people like politicians who do not understand them. For that reason I am happy to continue working in Dzununcam while learning about the common issues in rural Latin America firsthand, in addition to gathering information in order to solve these problems. Don't worry, I'm still going to try to make a plan this week to organize my own birding trips for kids next week.
Before left for Mexico, I was warned to expect the unexpected when working with a Latin American non-governmental organization. Initially, I thought this meant, "Be prepared for things like last-minute changes of plan, walking alone in the rain through flooded city streets while searching for a cab home, and digestive dystopia." While all of this may have already happened in the last week, I did not expect to have to rethink the entire purpose of why I am here.
After settling down in the city of Mérida last week, I began working with NyC's environmental education team on their water conservation project. After the first two days of simply observing their staff give presentations about water conservation to students at an elementary school, I realized it was going to be a lot harder than I expected to do what I came here wanting to do: make a real and immediate difference by taking kids out into nature and showing them beauty waiting to be discovered. It finally hit me that because of various logistical reasons I wasn't going to get to do this until the middle of July, at the earliest.
Fortunately, that same day I met with Barbara MacKinnon, bird conservation legend in the Yucatán Peninsula. Barbara has been working in the Yucatán for over 40 years and possibly has more on-the-ground conservation experience than anyone else here. She is a true conservationist. Although she has conducted some bird population surveys, she quickly denies that she is a scientist. Chatting with her I quickly learned that we share many of the same frustrations with the limiting mindset of "pure science". Given her extensive background, she was the perfect person to express my summer concerns to. Among many things, Barbara reminded me that it is important to observe before doing but it is also up to me to take the initiative to do the things I want to do. She also told me that the most important thing I can do here is show local people their worth by bringing out the knowledge of nature they already have and showing them it is valuable.
Students eager to answer a question about water conservation
The next two days I went with NyC to the rural village of Dzununcam to help conduct interviews with the landowners about their water use and contamination. While this type of work isn't why I came to Mexico, in these two days I feel like I gained more insight on Latin American conservation than I have in two years at Cornell. Throughout my travels in Latin America I have driven by dozens of poor villages like Dzununcam, but this was the first time I have spent hours walking through the streets, going into people's farms and houses, and actually talking to them. I wish I had photos to show exactly what this place is like, but bringing a camera would have been inappropriate so for now I'll play reporter.
The first man we interviewed went on a ten-minute rant about the government after we asked if he received any governmental support for his farm. He explained how he has seen over and over how political candidates come and visit his village, promise change and support, and then never return. He believes that the government is unfair and corrupt has no intention of helping people like him. The third person we interviewed was a man from Mérida who runs a tiny (and disgusting) pig farm in Dzununcam. While at first he tried to turn us away by saying he had work to do, after just a few questions he was showing us around his property and talking his head off about his problems. His place is absolutely revolting. In addition to the mountains of junk and garbage piled everywhere, the place reeks of pig feces. I looked into his well, the thing that we were there to interview him about, and saw that the shallow, black puddle at the bottom was moving, literally squirming with thousands of some kind of larvae. He brought us into his house, which is a dark shack extremely cluttered with rusty, damp, molding, and crusty things everywhere. Like the previous man, he receives no support from the government and angrily asserts that the government only cares about tax-generating people who work for large businesses. The rest, like him, are nothing more than animals to the government. Yet while he believes that the government looks down on him, he as well looks down with racism at the indigenous people of this village, calling them "indios salvages", savage indians, who have nothing better to do than go out and hunt wild animals. While we were trying to ask him about things like water contamination, he just couldn't stop telling us about how these "indians" are sabotaging his farm by poisoning his pigs and stealing his fish. He also sees them regularly going out to hunt birds, anteaters, and even Oncillas, a rare and threatened feline.
The place I have just described is actually part of an ecological reserve. If you have never lived in Latin America, you may not realize the disturbing lack of law enforcement there. It is not uncommon, I've found, for natural reserves to be heavily developed, deforested, and exploited. Three of the five people we interviewed didn't even know of the reserve they were living in. While declaring a forest a State Park in the U.S. may be enough to save it and its wildlife from destruction, I am starting to understand why it will not in Mexico. In countries like Mexico, it is more important than ever to collaborate with local communities to come up with solutions that benefit both people and nature. Otherwise neither will succeed in the long run.
This seems like an extremely hard thing to do. While I do believe that nature is essential to people, it's hard at times to see how to make the two work together. Granted, I have interviewed very small number of people, but most of them have seemed far too focused on their worries to ever care about nature. I don't know how to describe it exactly, but as soon as I look one of these people in the eye and began to listen to them, it feels overwhelmingly impossible to try to get them to care about nature. They just have too much else to worry about.
Which is why I wanted to work with kids. Even in these villages, they are generally happy and outgoing. It was quite a curveball to realize that I'm not going to work with them as much as I thought I would this summer, but I am learning to make the most of this as a learning experience. The biggest change is that for at least half of the summer I will be just learning, instead of teaching and learning. But the things I'm learning are extremely important to my future in conservation. I have learned that rural people will not trust people like politicians who do not understand them. For that reason I am happy to continue working in Dzununcam while learning about the common issues in rural Latin America firsthand, in addition to gathering information in order to solve these problems. Don't worry, I'm still going to try to make a plan this week to organize my own birding trips for kids next week.
-E.B.
Photo highlights from last weekend in Celestún:
Photo slideshow of the elementary school we went to in Mérida: www.ebarrientos.smugmug.com/merida
Photo highlights from last weekend in Celestún:
White-lored Gnatcatcher
Mexican Sheartail, a Mexican endemic
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)